The High Court in Mbale has dismissed a businessman’s attempt to revive a Shs167 million lawsuit against Tropical Bank Limited after finding that he failed to serve the bank with court documents within the legally prescribed time, dealing another blow to his efforts to pursue compensation over an alleged breach of a tenancy agreement.
In a ruling delivered on November 17, 2026, Justice Lubega Farouq dismissed an application by Sulaiman Mafabi seeking to overturn an earlier dismissal of his civil suit against the financial institution.
The court also ordered Mafabi to pay costs to Tropical Bank.
Mafabi had sued Tropical Bank in Civil Suit No. 19 of 2021, seeking to recover Shs167 million over an alleged breach of a tenancy agreement dated September 13, 2019.
He filed the suit on November 1, 2021, and the bank subsequently lodged its defence on November 17, 2021.
However, the case stalled after court directed the parties to file witness statements and scheduled a conference for April 11, 2023.
According to the court record, Mafabi and his lawyers failed to appear or take steps to advance the matter between April 11 and November 30, 2023.
The bank subsequently drew the court’s attention to Order 11A Rule 8 of the Civil Procedure Rules, arguing that the plaintiff and his lawyers had demonstrated a lack of interest in prosecuting the case.
The suit was consequently dismissed on November 30, 2023, with costs.
Seven-month delay sinks Shs167m case
Unwilling to let the dismissal stand, Mafabi returned to court on December 20, 2024, seeking reinstatement of the original suit and an opportunity to have his claim determined on its merits.
He argued that he had complied with court directions by filing his witness statement on June 15, 2023, and that the Deputy Registrar had indicated that the matter would be forwarded to a judge for further management.
Mafabi further claimed that neither he nor his lawyer had received a hearing notice informing them of the proceedings that ultimately resulted in the dismissal of the case.
He told court that he only discovered that his suit had been dismissed on October 15, 2024, while following up on its progress.
He maintained that he remained interested in pursuing the claim and that refusing to reinstate the suit would cause him damage.
But Tropical Bank mounted a strong opposition, accusing Mafabi and his legal team of neglecting the case for an extended period.
The bank’s representative, Bamweyana Asuman, who was identified as its Secretary and Head of Legal, argued that the application was fundamentally defective and that Mafabi had failed to demonstrate sufficient grounds for reopening the dismissed proceedings.
The bank also disputed Mafabi’s claim that witness statements had been filed and served, insisting that no such statements had been filed in court or served on its lawyers.
It further argued that Mafabi had failed to attend court throughout the two years the matter was pending.
Court exposes fatal procedural mistake
However, the decisive issue was not whether Mafabi had a legitimate claim against the bank, but whether he had complied with the legal requirements governing service of court documents.
Tropical Bank raised a preliminary objection, arguing that Mafabi had served his application for reinstatement outside the time prescribed by the Civil Procedure Rules.
The bank’s lawyers pointed out that although the application was endorsed by the court in January 2025, Mafabi did not serve it on the bank’s lawyers until August 25, 2025.
That was more than seven months after the application had been issued.
Under Order 5 Rule 1(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules, summons must ordinarily be served within 21 days of issuance. An extension may be granted upon application made within 15 days after expiry of the initial period, provided sufficient reasons are demonstrated.
The court also relied on Order 49 Rule 2, which requires orders, notices and documents to be served in the manner prescribed for service of summons.
Justice Lubega agreed with the bank’s argument, emphasising that the requirements governing service of summons also apply to applications and hearing notices.
The judge cited the Supreme Court decision in Kanyabwera v Tumwebwa [2005] 2 EA 86 and the High Court decision in Amdan v Stanbic Bank (U) Ltd, which addressed the application of summons service requirements to other court processes.
Justice Lubega noted that the Notice of Motion was endorsed by the court registrar on January 15, 2025, meaning Mafabi was required to serve it by February 12, 2025.
Instead, service was effected on August 25, 2025.
More damagingly, Mafabi had not filed an application seeking an extension of time to serve the documents.
The judge consequently upheld Tropical Bank’s preliminary objection, finding that the applicant had failed to comply with mandatory procedural requirements.
Judge declines to examine merits of Shs167m dispute
With the preliminary objection upheld, the court found that the procedural defect was sufficient to dispose of the entire application.
Justice Lubega therefore declined to consider Tropical Bank’s second objection or examine the substantive merits of Mafabi’s request to have the original suit reinstated.
The ruling means that Mafabi’s attempt to reopen Civil Suit No. 19 of 2021 has failed, leaving the November 2023 dismissal intact.
The judge ordered the application dismissed with costs to Tropical Bank.
The ruling was delivered electronically to the advocates representing both parties on November 17, 2026.














