damaging observation, the judge blamed the petitioner’s legal team for mishandling the evidence, warning that the failure to properly prepare the affidavits may have affected the outcome of the case.
“The blame goes to the counsel who mishandled that evidence. Probably it would have made a difference,” the judge observed.
The court also struck out Kiyaga’s supplementary affidavit, filed in September 2026, approximately four months after the initial pleadings had closed. The judge ruled that it introduced material after the close of pleadings without leave of court and could not be used to repair the petition.
Disputed election results and alleged alterations
At the centre of the petition were allegations that declaration of results forms from 24 polling stations had been altered, resulting in discrepancies between copies allegedly issued to candidates’ agents and certified copies later obtained from the Electoral Commission.
Kiyaga argued that the disputed forms contained overwritten figures and unexplained changes that favoured Kyambadde.
He maintained that the differences were substantial enough to overturn the declared result, which gave Kyambadde 27,075 votes against his 24,801, a margin of 2,274 votes.
His lawyers argued that the disputed alterations had moved the electoral margin by thousands of votes and that the certified documents used by the Electoral Commission did not reflect the figures originally recorded and issued at polling stations.
However, the court found that the petitioner’s case heavily depended on uncertified declaration of results forms whose sources had not been adequately established.
The judge held that certified copies obtained from the Electoral Commission took precedence over the uncertified documents presented by Kiyaga, particularly because the evidence of 22 agents who could have authenticated the latter had been struck out.
The court further relied on the testimony of Mpigi District Returning Officer Twinomujuni Everest, who maintained that the disputed forms were received from presiding officers in the condition in which they were later presented during tallying.
Twinomujuni explained that the alterations could have resulted from corrections made by presiding officers while filling in the declaration forms.
He also told court that the forms were displayed and read during the tallying exercise before Kyambadde was declared winner in the presence of candidates and their agents.
Crucially, Kiyaga admitted during cross-examination that he had not raised a complaint when the results were displayed, read and tallied at the district tally centre.
Justice Karemani said the returning officer’s explanation had not been controverted by credible evidence.
The judge emphasised that alterations to election documents can constitute a criminal offence under Section 95(a) of the Parliamentary Elections Act, but that the mere presence of alterations does not automatically establish fraud.
The petitioner had to demonstrate that the changes were motivated by fraudulent or ulterior intentions.
The court concluded that the possibility that the changes were corrections of errors prevailed and found no proof of fraudulent manipulation.
Court rules Kyambadde was eligible to contest
Kiyaga had also challenged Kyambadde’s eligibility, arguing that she was serving as a Senior Presidential Advisor and had not lawfully resigned from public service within the required period before nomination.
He argued that her resignation was ineffective because the letter was addressed to the Secretary, Office of the President rather than directly to the President, whom he considered her appointing authority.
However, Justice Karemani ruled that Kyambadde’s position as Senior Presidential Advisor did not make her a public officer within the meaning of Article 175 of the Constitution and Section 2 of the Public Service Act.
The judge observed that Presidential Advisors were categorised as political leaders under the 2025/2026 salary structure issued by the Ministry of Public Service.
Consequently, the court held that she was not subject to the requirement compelling public officers to resign at least 90 days before nomination in order to contest parliamentary elections.
The judge also found that Kyambadde had, in any case, submitted a resignation letter dated May 23, 2025, which was accepted by the Secretary, Office of the President, in a letter dated June 10, 2025.
The court further ruled that Kiyaga had lost the opportunity to challenge her nomination after failing to raise the matter before the Electoral Commission during the nomination process.
According to the judgment, Kiyaga admitted that he had never inspected Kyambadde’s nomination documents or formally complained to the Electoral Commission before the election.
The judge said pre-election disputes concerning a candidate’s eligibility should be raised and resolved through the Electoral Commission’s established procedures rather than being introduced after the election.
Missing agent signatures did not invalidate results
The petitioner also challenged declaration of results forms from several polling stations because they lacked signatures from candidates’ agents and did not contain explanations for their failure to sign.
The court acknowledged that several forms were signed only by presiding officers, with no recorded reasons explaining the absence of agents’ signatures.
However, Justice Karemani ruled that the absence of agents’ signatures did not automatically invalidate election results, provided the presiding officer had signed the declaration forms.
The judge described the presiding officer as the mandatory and principal signatory responsible for the declaration of results forms.
The court therefore found that the failure by candidates’ agents to sign the forms, or the failure to record reasons for not signing, did not by itself amount to non-compliance sufficient to invalidate the election.
Kyambadde retains parliamentary seat
Ultimately, the court found that Kiyaga had failed to establish the alleged electoral irregularities and their effect on the election.
Since the judge found no proven non-compliance with electoral laws, he ruled that there was no need to proceed to the question of whether any irregularities had substantially affected the election outcome.
The petition was consequently dismissed, and Kyambadde was confirmed as the directly elected Member of Parliament for Mawokota County North.
In a notable decision on costs, the judge ordered each party to bear its own legal expenses, reasoning that election petitions are matters of public interest involving not only candidates but also the voters they represent.
Justice Karemani cautioned against discouraging aggrieved voters and candidates from seeking judicial redress through punitive costs awards.
The judgment leaves Kyambadde’s victory intact, while highlighting the importance of properly prepared affidavit evidence and the need for candidates to challenge nomination irregularities through the prescribed legal channels before polling day.













