Three children of late businessman James Musinguzi Garuga have launched a fresh attack on their brother Alwyn and former minister Matthew Rukikaire, accusing them of using security agencies to harass the family and business associates in an escalating dispute over their father’s estate and companies.
The bitter succession and corporate ownership dispute surrounding the late businessman James Musinguzi Garuga has taken another dramatic turn, with three of his children publicly accusing their brother, Alwyn Carl Musinguzi, and businessman Matthew Rukikaire of allegedly turning state institutions into weapons in a battle over their father’s business empire.
In a strongly worded press statement dated November 16, 2026, Rowena Musinguzi, Johnnie Musinguzi and Phillip Musinguzi said they had endured more than a year of harassment following their father’s death and accused the two men of instigating criminal complaints against family members and longstanding business associates.
The siblings specifically questioned the involvement of the State House Anti-Corruption Unit and the Land Police Protection Unit in what they described as private family and commercial disputes.
Their statement comes amid renewed investigations into transactions involving property previously owned by Garuga, including a controversial land deal on Koome Island in Mukono District that has triggered police summons and competing claims over ownership.
“We wonder what role and mandate these State agents have in a private family estate,” the siblings said, challenging the handling of complaints involving transactions they insist were legally concluded by their father during his lifetime.
They maintain that the transactions under investigation were supported by documentation held by government institutions, including local government offices, the Uganda Revenue Authority (URA), the Financial Intelligence Authority (FIA), commercial banks and lawyers involved in the transactions.
The siblings argue that the existence of these records should make it possible for investigators to independently establish the circumstances surrounding the transactions.
The Koome Island land controversy
The latest confrontation centres partly on a disputed transaction involving approximately 296.74 hectares of land at Busanga on Koome Island, Mukono District.
The controversy emerged after Alwyn raised questions about how the land, which he says belonged to his late father, was leased to Erunger Property Limited, a company linked to British nationals.
According to reporting by The Source in October 2026, the disputed property was the subject of a 99-year lease agreement dated December 17, 2024, with a stated premium of approximately US$3.3 million.
The agreement identified Mani Stephen as the lessor, while Alwyn questioned how he acquired the authority to transact over land he maintains was registered in his father’s name.
The matter prompted the Land Police Protection Unit to summon Garuga’s widow, Dr Peace Kesiime Musinguzi, lawyer Agaba Maguru and other individuals to explain their involvement in the transaction.
The police summons followed a complaint by Alwyn, who questioned the validity of the transaction and whether the stated payment had actually been made.
However, in their November 6 statement, Rowena, Johnnie and Phillip insist that the transactions being investigated were lawfully undertaken by their father while he was alive and mentally competent.
They also refer to Civil Suit No. 343 of 2025 before the High Court in Mukono, involving Alwyn, Mani Stephen, Erunger Property Limited and the Commissioner for Land Registration.
According to the siblings, the defendants presented evidence that Garuga sold the land in 2024, received payments directly into his personal bank account and that the subsequent transfer was registered and taxes paid.
They therefore reject attempts to criminalise the transaction, arguing that their father had the right to make decisions concerning his property during his lifetime.
The competing claims over the Koome Island property remain a central part of the unfolding dispute.
How the family feud started
The conflict intensified following Garuga’s death in August 2025, leaving behind a substantial business and property portfolio that has since become the subject of competing claims.
Garuga was a prominent businessman from the Kigezi sub-region, with interests in property, agriculture, hospitality and other investments. He was also a former political associate of Dr Kizza Besigye and served as a financial controller for Besigye’s 2001 presidential campaign.
His business interests included Incafex Limited, Garuga Properties Limited, Kinkizi Development Company Limited and investments associated with the Kigezi Highland Tea business.
Following his death, his widow, Dr Peace Kesiime Musinguzi, applied for letters of administration to manage his estate.
According to the November 6 statement, the family had initially agreed at a meeting that their mother should administer the estate and supported her application.
However, Alwyn subsequently lodged a caveat opposing the grant of letters of administration to his mother, triggering a succession dispute that has since spilled into multiple court proceedings.
The three siblings now supporting their mother claim Alwyn was estranged from their father for several years and had previously sued him and his companies in 2018 and 2019.
They further accuse him of joining forces with Rukikaire to pursue control of companies in which their father held shares.
These allegations represent the siblings’ account of the family conflict and have not been established as judicial findings.
Court intervenes in estate management
The dispute over who should administer Garuga’s estate eventually reached the High Court Family Division in Kampala.
In a ruling delivered on February 20, 2026, Justice John Eudes Keitirima appointed the Administrator General, Victor Manzi, as temporary administrator of the estate pending resolution of the succession dispute.
The court declined Alwyn’s application for joint temporary administration, citing the serious disagreements among family members.
Justice Keitirima observed that the beneficiaries could not work harmoniously and that appointing members of the divided family to administer the estate risked further disruption.
The judge said the estate needed to be protected from possible waste and interference while the substantive dispute was being resolved.
Alwyn had argued that the estate was worth more than Shs1 trillion and accused his mother of undervaluing its assets.
Peace Kesiime disputed his claims, maintaining that some of the businesses and properties cited by her son were separate legal entities and could not automatically be treated as personal estate assets.
The appointment of the Administrator General was therefore an attempt by the court to safeguard the estate rather than hand control to either faction.
The November 6 statement now adds another dimension to the dispute, with the three siblings openly aligning themselves with their mother and challenging their brother’s actions.
The 22-year Rukikaire-Incafex battle
Perhaps the most consequential aspect of the latest statement is its renewed focus on Rukikaire’s longstanding legal battle with Incafex Limited, a company associated with the late Garuga.
The dispute is not new.
According to court records and reporting by Daily Monitor, the disagreement dates back to 2004, when Rukikaire petitioned the High Court, claiming that Incafex was conducting its affairs in an oppressive manner and excluding him from company meetings and financial information.
Garuga, then the company’s managing director, opposed the petition, arguing that Rukikaire had not paid for the 450 shares allotted to him and was holding them in trust for a foreign company.
The litigation travelled through the High Court, Court of Appeal and Supreme Court.
In 2017, the Supreme Court ruled in Rukikaire’s favour on the question of his shareholding, finding that he qualified as a shareholder despite the dispute over payment for the allotted shares.
The case continued to generate litigation, with Daily Monitor reporting in March 2023 that Incafex had challenged proceedings before the Supreme Court, arguing that an earlier application had already been dismissed.
The three Garuga siblings now argue that Rukikaire has continued pursuing interests in the company despite their father’s death and the ongoing succession dispute.
They also allege that Rukikaire misrepresented facts in his longstanding court battle with Incafex.
In their statement, they refer to a letter allegedly written by President Yoweri Museveni to the Attorney General and the Minister of Lands, Housing and Urban Development, referenced PO/17, which they claim exposes misrepresentations in the dispute.
The contents and implications of that presidential correspondence were not independently established from the material available for this report.
Importantly, the Supreme Court’s 2017 decision recognised Rukikaire’s shareholder status. His longstanding legal interest in Incafex therefore cannot simply be dismissed as a claim without judicial history.
Nine company accounts reportedly closed
The siblings have also raised concerns over the closure of nine bank accounts belonging to five companies in which their father held substantial shares.
They allege that on May 13, 2026, a police officer attached to the State House Anti-Corruption Unit, identified in their statement as D/AIP Charles Mugerwa, secured orders before the Buganda Road Magistrates Court leading to the closure of the accounts.
According to the siblings, the orders were obtained through an ex-parte hearing, with the officer reportedly relying on provisions of the Bankers Books Act and Sections 8, 9 and 31 of the Computer Misuse Act.
They further claim that when the companies sought legal redress to have the accounts reopened, Alwyn and his lawyers filed a defence on behalf of the police officer rather than the State Attorney.
The siblings say the accounts remain closed, leaving the affected companies struggling to meet commercial bank loan obligations, salaries, office rent, supplier payments, National Social Security Fund (NSSF) contributions and URA tax obligations.
These claims could not be independently confirmed from the court orders cited in the statement.
The allegations nevertheless raise questions about the circumstances surrounding the account closures, the legal basis of the orders and the extent to which the affected companies have been able to challenge them.
Fresh corporate battles at URSB
The dispute has also extended to the Uganda Registration Services Bureau (URSB), where competing interests have emerged over the management of companies associated with Garuga.
In May 2026, URSB dismissed three petitions filed by Alwyn challenging the appointment of lawyer Agaba Maguru as a director of Kinkizi Development Company Limited, Garuga Properties Limited and Incafex Limited.
However, the decision requires careful interpretation.
In its May 13 ruling, URSB Assistant Registrar of Companies Daniel Nasasira found that Alwyn lacked the necessary legal standing to bring the petitions because he was neither a registered shareholder of the companies nor the legally appointed representative of his father’s estate.
The registrar also noted that the estate was represented by the Administrator General and that related matters were already before the High Court.
Consequently, the petitions were dismissed without determining the substantive question of whether Maguru’s appointment was lawful.
In a separate development in July 2026, Rukikaire successfully challenged Maguru’s appointment as director of the three companies, with URSB overturning the appointments after finding that the process was unlawful.
Rukikaire had told URSB that he held a 0.45 per cent shareholding in Garuga Properties Limited, which is the majority shareholder in Kinkizi Development Company and Incafex.
The two decisions illustrate how the dispute has evolved beyond inheritance into a complicated battle over corporate governance, shareholding and control of businesses.
Siblings challenge Alwyn’s authority
In their latest statement, Rowena, Johnnie and Phillip argue that Alwyn and Matthew Rukikaire have no legal mandate to challenge decisions their father made concerning his personal property and business interests while he was alive.
They maintain that their father was in good health and of sound mind when he undertook the transactions now being questioned.
They also accuse the two men of using criminal complaints and police summons to intimidate their mother, other family members and their father’s longstanding business associates.
The siblings insist that transactions involving their father’s property should be examined against documentary evidence rather than subjected to what they describe as politically and commercially motivated criminal investigations.
They conclude that the continuing complaints and legal battles are causing financial damage to businesses that had operated for decades under their father’s leadership.
But with the estate administration still contested, company directorships challenged, bank accounts reportedly frozen and the Koome Island transaction under police scrutiny, the dispute is far from over.
What began as a disagreement over who should administer a deceased businessman’s estate has developed into a sprawling legal confrontation involving succession law, corporate ownership, multimillion-dollar property transactions and the role of state investigative agencies.
The November 6 statement signals that three of Garuga’s children are no longer content to let the dispute play out quietly in court.
The central question now is whether the competing claims over Garuga’s business empire can be resolved through transparent legal processes before the prolonged litigation causes further damage to the companies and assets at the centre of the family dispute.













